Jump to content
Dustloop Forums

Philosophy of Analyzing Losses by Nage


Kuuhaku
  • 2h5tz6v.jpg

    Earlier today Nage, a strong Faust player who placed 2nd at this year's Evolution 2015 and 2nd at last year's Arc Revolution Cup 2014 in GGXrd, posted a long document outlining his thought process when it comes to analyzing his losses in games in order to improve. The post has been translated and provides really insightful information to how players can productively approach losses. The scope of the post is with Guilty Gear  Xrd in mind, but is general enough to be applicable to anyone to plays fighting games.

Nage's Twitlonger

Translated Document

Credits to TENMA for the translation

 

Here I compile how I analyze ‘Why I Lost’, and what I do to fix them.

I divide this note to: figuring out  ‘Why I lost’; ‘when do I think about it’; and ‘philosophy on how to fix problems’.

 

This is my thought as a ‘Player who wants to leave results at a tournament’. It’ll be great if this note can inspire other theories.

 

  • Figuring out ‘Why I Lost’

I’m ‘continuously digging for reasons I lost’.

 

Why I continue searching  is due to these 3 points:

  1. What leads to ‘losing’ is due to multiple factors within a single match, and I want to find as many of those factors.

  2. To avoid difficult situations, theorize tactics that can prevent said situations.

  3. By determining the fine detail of  the problem, be able to find counter tactics easier.

 

For example: ‘First round, got setplayed to death and lost the round’.

 

‘Got setplayed to death’

= ‘got knocked down and lost’

-> What move caused me to get knocked down?

-> Why did I get hit by that move?

-> What can I do to prevent getting hit by this move?

 

‘Got setplayed to death’

= ‘Couldn’t get out of the setplay situation’

-> Why couldn’t I get out?

-> Was there anything I could do get out?

-> Where should I have used the burst?

-> How did I use my meter?

-> Could I have changed the situation if I prioritized on getting meter?

 

Like so, even in a round that finished quickly, I try to think of multiple points that could have been improved. If the round didn’t end instantly, then there’s more to think about.

 

Before analyzing ‘what to do in a difficult situation’ I think of ‘what to do before I’m in a difficult situation’.

 

This example goes outside the game, but if you ‘overslept and got to work late’, before  thinking about ‘how to prepare faster after waking up’, it’s better to think ‘how to avoid sleeping in’. Which then you can think of what to do after sleeping in, which may calm you down a bit too.

 

I think about how to avoid dangerous situations, and then think of what to do when you’re in the dangerous situation.

 

After generating few points, I pinpoint what should be fixed first, and then consider what the protocol should be. There are limits to how much I can think at once, so I prioritize on what I think are effective.

 

  • When to think about ‘Why I Lost’

  1. During the match (be aware).

  2. When re-watching the match to discover.

  3. Regardless of time and place, idea comes out of no where.

  4. Have someone else tell you.

 

For me it’s just those four.

 

(1) happens during a match, so usually leads to a loss.

With (2), I find being able to watch yourself from 3rd person perspective is beneficial. Watching your own matches allow you to  realize ‘what I should have done instead’.

(3) happens randomly. When it does I take notes so I don’t forget, and when I get the chance I test  it out.

 

I do my best to come up with the solution(s) myself, but if you think your perspective is narrow, have a trusted player watch over your back.

 

Also there are times losses cumulate (and become depressed about it), and you won’t be able to logically think of ‘Why I Lost’. When this happens (1) becomes impossible to do.

 

When aggravated you can attempt to calm yourself by digging for reasons, but if that doesn’t work I take a break. Do other things to calm down, then think of ‘Why I Lost’.

 

Even if I’m winning, I sometimes think about ‘If I do this and they do that I might lose, so I should think about what to do when they do that’.

 

  • What I’m Conscious of When Fixing the Issue

First, fixing the reason for losing does not directly lead to ‘winning’.

 

As stated earlier, “What leads to ‘losing’ is due to multiple factors within a single match”. Even if you fix one problem, sometimes you’ll lose due to  different reasons.

 

Winning is great, but even if you lose again it’s best to tell yourself  ‘I’m able to do something I couldn’t  do before’, and appreciate your own development.

I think  the mentality of ‘I’m grinding but doesn’t feel like I’m improving’ comes from the disruption of the core motivation of ‘fun’, so regardless of win/loss, being positive about your improvement is key.

 

If you eliminate reason of losing one by one, even if the results don’t come immediately, in the future your win rate stabilizes, and you become more confident in your decisions (have wider perspective).

 

  • Think “You can’t never lose”

No matter how much you fix, if you are facing a human, it’s impossible to have a 100% win rate. (This will be discussed in detail on another day).

 

With that in mind, to be able to win at a tournament and other high stakes moment, it is important to eliminate uncertain situations (have countermeasures) one by one.

 

My goal is to ‘leave results at a tournament’, so to achieve that I practice critical thinking during casuals, and be able to make confident decisions during tournaments.

 

That’s about it for this time.

TLDR: ‘I play games with longevity in mind’.


Thank you for reading!


  Report Article



User Feedback

Recommended Comments

tokin fuyou

Posted

This is really inspiring stuff. You can also apply it to life in general. I'll be keeping this in mind whenever I play again.

Djqubil

Posted

This is really good! Just noticed that you wrote Evolution 2014 instead of 2015. Might wanna fix that. :3

Kuuhaku

Posted

Fixed. 2014 was supposed to be for Arc Revo.



Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Upcoming Events

    No upcoming events found
  • Posts

    • Boston Blue Beat: Beach Episode 2026 was a super sick tournament! Here's the Top 8 if you missed it: https://x.com/BostonBlueBeat/status/2078917825465331972 And you can also watch those matches on Replay Theater, which has recently added Sailor Moon S as a game! We're currently moving through the backlog of events and adding them slowly, but there's already a bunch of timestamped matches for each character from many different levels of play. In other news, HeatXD's BSNES fork has an update that does away with port forwarding and now utilizes his Weyvelength lobbies, making it much easier to connect to people. Check it out here - https://github.com/HeatXD/bsnes-netplay/releases If you're interested in using it to netplay Sailor Moon S or any other SNES games, the Moonlight Fight Society discord is a great place to find matches!  
    • Normal.mp4 There is this combo I've been doing for a while now. Normally it looks like this because I usually if not every time do it from point blank range. I randomly set the setting to close range instead and then I sometimes but not always got this other result where the combo ends on the opposite side that I start it from.   SideSwap.mp4   I feel that this would actually be good if I could do it on command since it would let me do a the full combo while also picking what side I end on. But alas I can't figure out how to do that. Any feedback would be appreciated.  
    • How about choosing between XXAC+R or XRD Rev2? Which game is more interesting or more beneficial to fundamentals?
    • I don't have the mod unfortunately (and I'm not really comfortable with installing one).   I'm looking at the boxes for 6H here (https://www.dustloop.com/w/GGST/May) and it seems her hurtbox (the teal boxes) doesn't extend past the edge of her outstretched hand. Looking at Ky's 5P hitbox (https://www.dustloop.com/w/GGST/Ky_Kiske), it seems like that wouldn't extend past his fingertips (the red boxes). I'm in training mode now, and there isn't any way for Ky's fingertips to come even close to May's outstretched hand in this scenario, yet the punish damage still happens.   The only way how that can still occur and the wiki also be correct is if May's hurtbox stays by her fingertips during active frames, but somehow grows to an enormous size encompassing her entire anchor on whiff. Is this what you mean by "extended" hurtbox? How would I be able to tell when / how / whether a hurtbox has been extended? (I don't see anything in the wiki regarding character-specific extended hurtboxes for character-specific movesets)   I'm confused... what am I missing here?   EDIT: I found a very old version of her hurtbox dating back to June 2021 where it DOES cover the entire anchor. I see that this was changed back in Oct 2024 so that should be old info, but if GGST 2.0 somehow reverted back to the ancient hurtboxes then that could explain what I'm seeing (https://www.dustloop.com/w/File:GGST_May_6H-2-Hitbox.png). That would be a crazy oversight though, as I'm not seeing this in any of the official patch notes. I doubt that's the case.
    • No, disjoints did not get any changes. If you're doing this kind of test, make sure you have a hitbox viewer mod installed so you can see for yourself ingame.   What I'm suspecting is that ky's 5P is hitting may's extended hurtbox that lingers when 6H whiffs
×
×
  • Create New...