Next Level Arcade NYC
http://www.nycnextlevel.com/
There is listed hours and fee charges. People generally play fighting games, with SFIVAE and UMvC3 the most popular, however people play a good amount of games out, including Blazblue (me for instance). It's in an area surrounded by asian (mainly chinese) restuaraunts.
I was around there during it's closed openings, but now it's open to the public.
If your sour about Chinatown Fair, a lot of vets from there are here now and this place is most crowded (active) on Weds, Fridays and Saturdays.
Regards,
Legit