tolore,
How can you say, "top players cannot get eliminated before their time this way( if they lose it won't be because of the randomeness of the bracket, it'll be because they aren't good enough)" [sic]? If a top player loses early on, then he deserves to lose. He obviously wasn't good enough to win, if he lost that early. If top player A loses to top player B early on, he more than likely won't beat him further on in the finals. If he stands a chance at all, he is more likely to beat him early on anyway because he'll be playing at his best without the fatigue of the entire tournament behind him. The only reason he should play worse is if he's psyching himself out because he has to fight another top player. If you can't win with a random bracket, you're not going to win.