this is an arbitrary distinction at best.
put down your pitchfork, because there's simply no moral high ground in this argument at all. the fact of the matter is, we're all exploiting the legal gray area of most anime not being licensed outside of japan. and if you think any torrent site is not AT LEAST breaking even due to ad revenue and donations, you're insane. if you want your pirated anime, you're going to have to live with the fact that regardless of how you're getting it, SOMEONE, SOMEWHERE, is making money off of it.
could we please not resort to using the i word? it brings down the level of class in here.
so i had a pretty long post written out, but i realized that most of it was stuff that aj either already knew or was simply not going to budge on.
but, i want to make it clear that i'm not saying bittorrent has no practical application or that torrents are inherently bad; actually, the bittorrent protocol does what it's supposed to very well. the issue is that people of all levels of technical knowledge fail to understand how they're supposed to be used; from the scrubs who don't know that you have to seed to get good download speed, to the dicks who spend money to prevent you from seeding on private trackers- none of them get that torrents are only useful (and superior to everything else) when everyone seeds. because of excessive leeching (in part due to seedboxes not letting people seed), the asinine ratio policies of many trackers, and the generally terrible community of file sharers who take as much as they can while giving as little as possible, i have mostly given up on torrents.
while it still baffles me that anyone would consider spending money on a server to seed torrents instead of directly hosting files, i'll just leave the subject alone since i've already gayed up the norcal thread once again for too many pages anyways.
(we're still friends, right? )